Scientists do not agree that plant life isn’t sentient. It’s a “maybe, we don’t really know” type of situation.
Just for the record.
The whole discussion is just vain, because animals don’t manifest out of thin air. They themselves eat plants. And they eat more plants than when we eat the plants directly, because they need some of that energy to sustain their own life as well.
So, if someone wants to kill as few plants as possible, then they should follow a plant-based diet.
https://pmc.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/articles/PMC8052213/
A.Plants do not show proactive behaviour.
B.Classical learning does not indicate consciousness, so reports of such learning in plants are irrelevant.
C.The considerable differences between the electrical signals in plants and the animal nervous system speak against a functional equivalence. Unlike in animals, the action potentials of plants have many physiological roles that involve Ca2+ signaling and osmotic control; and plants’ variable potentials have properties that preclude any conscious perception of wounding as pain.
D. In plants, no evidence exists of reciprocal (recurrent) electrical signaling for integrating information, which is a prerequisite for consciousness.
E.Most proponents of plant consciousness also say that all cells are conscious, a speculative theory plagued with counterevidence.
Scientists do agree that plants do not possess the capacity for consciousness. Anyone claiming otherwise is either misinterpreting what the science says or are being deceitful to justifty animal slaughter.
To put it into perspective: Try justifying the exploitative abuse and slaughter of humans by saying that a human and a blueberry bush are effectively the same in terms of sentience or consciousness. Silly, right?
Animals are sentient. Plants are not.
I’ve watched multiple leatures from top scientists that all day “we do not really know for sure”.
To state factually that they are not sentient is an emotional thing for you and not science fact.That is an interesting read, thank you. Proactivity is definitely an aspect to consider.
Even if plants are somehow conscious despite lacking a brain and nervous system, most plants are fed to animals before those animals are then fed to humans.
Meaning vegans eat less plants than non-vegans while abstaining from eating animals who unequivocally are sentient and conscious. Plants are not sentient.
That’s a stretch. Plants are not known to be sentient or not.
Circular reasoning. I presented you with a concrete argument against plant sentience and you continue to say otherwise, despite not presenting anything to support your argument.
I’m not going to go search copy and paste the first result I see. It’s not that important to me. I’m just letting you know that people who dedicate their lives to things like this do not agree if plant life is sentient. That’s all. I’m not the one that’s debating, the experts are doing that for us.
Removed by mod
I mean, honey is literally an animal product, therefore making it not vegan by default.
Removed by mod
I hope to god this is a jerk
I’ve never seen someone try to apply centerism to this topic
Literally “both-sides” to killing animals
Vegans don’t want your respect. They want you to stop exploiting animals.
They got banned for a hat trick of rule violations
I broke my own rule of not responding seriously but I’m only so strong 😅
Honey is not even something we need to sustain ourselves and has plenty of alternatives like agave or maple syrup.
I don’t understand how abstaining from honey is what makes veganism extreme.
Bees don’t need or care about the fruit. Plants produce fruit to spread their seeds. Bees do need their honey though.
That’s why veganism should be defined by speciesism Taking honey from bees, especially if it is “farmed” is an act of speciesism because humans think they are entitled to the labour of this creature and they do not require it to live.
Eating plants is not speciesism because it is not an act this is humans exerting their power over a living thing, it’s a common trait among a wide variety of animals and not dependent on power imbalance. And we require it to live. Wild animals hunting each other for food is not speciesism because those animals need to do that to live. Humans do not, in most cases.




